Showing posts with label fairy tales. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fairy tales. Show all posts

Sunday, March 23, 2014

AS YOU WISH

INCONCEIVABLE


Are you kidding me? Why haven't I read this until now? This should be a staple book for 7th-9th grade. When I finally become king of America, I'll require it in every classroom. Sword fights! Pirates! Thieves! Monsters! Adventure! Action! And, I suppose, love. 

It's the third installment of 1970's month. Although it was published in that decade, it's a timeless classic, and a shoe-in for inclusion in the vaunted SHELF OF FAME. 

And these guys! Inconceivable! You killed my father, prepare to die! Anybody want a peanut?

This is an all-timer, and not just because of the movie, which continues to captivate; but it is part of the equation of success. If I ever trick someone into having a kid with me, this will be the first movie s/he views, and probably the only one until s/he is old enough to appreciate Godard and Eisenstein and pretend s/he is smarter and deeper than me. 

Where to begin praising this book? Probably the beginning. William Goldman is a clever fellow, and his vitae is long and storied, but this The Princess Bride (TPB) is his best, by far. Part of what makes this book so great is that Goldman himself wrote the screenplay for the movie, with most of the scenes inserted verbatim, which makes imagining these scenes unfolding all the better as I read; the faces and voices were there. Some might say that seeing the movie first, then reading the book is going to taint the experience of the book, but I argue that in this case, it's enhanced. For one, THE SAME GUY wrote both. Second, it's his vision of the book in film form. Third, by virtue of 1 and 2, the story is not butchered for popular consumption, nor are key details changed that enrage the people who like to bemoan how movies ruin books, like this lady.

If you clicked the link, you'll notice that the author leads off with The Scarlet Letter. As I started TPB, the first comparison that came to mind was The Custom House, the horribly dull introduction to Hawthorne's work. It's what, 43 pages? All he had to write was, "Hey, I found this story of Puritan scandal in a trunk in a stuffy old attic. It's pretty good. Let's read it together." UUUUGGGHHHH I remember having to read that turgid glacier of an introduction in high school. What a drag. Conversely, Goldman sets up the story of TPB with actual fanfare and meaningful context. This exposition of how the story came about is long and slow-paced, but is much more engaging than The Custom House. However, there is some material about staring at some actress in a swimsuit that made me uncomfortable. (Here, the italics indicate that I am one whose comfort zone is expansive, and that usually it takes something extreme to, as they say, get my goat.) Probably because I want kids to read this book. Now I'll get angry emails and calls from parents who think I am promoting perversion. Goldman saves the introduction with the discussion of his father reading the (fictional) S. Morgenstern classic book to him as a child, and Goldman's lifelong desire to publish an abridged version. There's some satire here that will fly over a kid's head, but I got it. Yay me. This part of the introduction, and the periodic interjections by Goldman throughout the story, are transferred to the film in the grand-dad / grandson moments with Peter Falk and Fred Savage. 

After the introduction, the story begins in earnest. For the sake of pacing in the movie, the personal histories of the main characters are jettisoned, and in the book they provide much-needed new information that gives us a deeper understanding of Prince Humperdinck, Inigo, Fezzik, and Buttercup. And my goodness, how fascinating these histories are! I'm thankful for them, as they provide excellent fodder for discussions of character motivations and developing rounded, full personalities within a book. 

Then, there is the narrative. It's like watching the movie again, with some slight, but not debilitating, differences. It moves right along, as Goldman promises, and his interjections and certain parts of the abridgments are entertaining. I worried that he would get too cute with them and bring the story to a screeching halt over and over, but it's tastefully done, and he wisely chooses the right spots. 

I WOULD NOT SAY SUCH THINGS IF I WERE YOU

I wanted my room to look like this when I was a kid.
And I wanted Peter Falk to read bedtime stories to me.
I never got what I wanted. 
So many themes emerge as one reads. Allow me to cover them in convenient list form:

  1. Father-son relationship
  2. The importance of stories in our culture/childhoods
  3. Standard tropes of fairy tales
  4. The role of true love in stories
  5. Loneliness and friendship
  6. Solidarity and betrayal
  7. Finding one's place in society
  8. Passing the torch (in lots of ways)
  9. Nagging wives (introduction only) 
  10. Death and Life
  11. Life isn't fair
  12. The eternal presence of pain
There are more one could tease out and analyze, I'm sure, but I don't work for Spark Notes, so forget about it. With the wealth of themes, motifs, and symbols within this story, one could run the 8/9 gamut of literature standards in this one book. If I could go back in time and hypnotize my English teacher into scuttling The Scarlet Letter and replacing it with TPB, I would. I'd also kick myself for using time travel so frivolously. I want to use this in a literature class to deconstruct fairy tales and fantasy books, so that the kiddos and I can examine and make fun of them, and by doing so, understand them. It's like bullying, but with a purpose.  

There is not much more I can add to the extant literature about this book and film combination. That many people appreciate it and hand it down through their generations demonstrates that some of us still have taste and decency, but also that we're proving Goldman's point of the importance of stories that are shared across families and generations as a way to connect, to bond, and to establish common mythology, but also common values. 

What's most impressive to me about Goldman is the ease and brevity with which he creates a fictional world. They're the Cliffs of Insanity because...they're the cliffs of insanity! We can fill in the rest. The rodents of unusual size? Sure, they're real. When reading fantasy, we do suspend disbelief, and Goldman plays with that, but everything seems so logical, especially in the way that he categorizes and ranks things throughout the book - most people will probably remember the most powerful kisses narration by Peter Falk near the end of the film. Goldman throws in similar silliness with timing the invention of certain things and ideas, which, in the world of The Princess Bride, makes sense, but in our boring old world, would be highly illogical, Captain. 

It's the perfect mix of comedy, wit, drama, intrigue, and adventure within a timeless setting, without resorting to the scope and length of the 1000-page epics. I suppose that's why he's a celebrated author for a living and I post this drivel for free. 

Mawidge.

The frenzied ending might be my favorite part of the book. Here, Goldman gives us exact times for every single encounter and action and the story hurtles toward its inevitable conclusion. I remember thinking at one point, there are only 25 pages left in this book; how will Goldman pull this off? I'm irritated, but extremely curious. Now, the very end, in which Goldman gives his final commentary, leaves a cliffhanger, but is mirrored well in the movie, leaving us to question what happens after the story ends. Obviously, that is up to the reader, which is the power of literature and imagination. Do we want a happy ending? Should there be extended conflict? Will *shudder* there be a sequel? So, there's some satire around happy endings, which is fine. How would you expect something like this to end other than how it started - with a laugh. 

Okay, I'll stop fawning now.

NEXT TIME, I YELL ABOUT

The fourth, and probably last, book in 1970's month. Let's just say that I hear this one A LOT!



BORING STUFF

William Goldman
1973 Del Rey

Monday, January 21, 2013

Knives, Lies, and Videotape

First dates are always awkward.

In which the author reviews the book and alerts you to the pun in the title of this blog entry

Lies, Knives, and Girls in Red Dresses is an engaging study of fairy tales, mythical characters, and their dark subtexts, in verse. Featuring stark silhouette illustrations to punctuate the capabilities of evil within, the book provides us an alternate view of stories we thought we knew. Ron Koertge offers us an epilogue to The Emperor's New Clothes, a valley-girl version of Little Red Riding Hood, and a modern take on The Ugly Duckling that might help explain to the uninformed why some young adults seem so hard to reach. I highly recommend this book to anyone who values the "out-there" literature, or simply enjoys satire. Further, the poetic form might serve to open doors for YA readers to discover more verse, and to dispel any preconceived notions of poetry as a mode of expressing feelings about flowers, an attitude I've often encountered in my classroom. 

Great pun, JB! It works on so many levels. Two, to be exact. 

In which the author defends "graphic" novels and alerts you to the pun in this very heading

Defining the limits of what's appropriate for students to read in school is an ongoing issue. I would have no problem allowing a student to read this book and do some kind of project on it. 

1.) Many of the reviews of this book on Amazon label it graphic and disturbing. Relative to what these people normally read, probably, but it's not graphic in the sense that the author goes into gory detail or uses foul language. Rather, he uses the poetic form to great effect by sparing us much of the detail and letting us fill in with our imagination, much the same as the cautionary children's tales that he twists or tells from a different perspective. 

2.) Part of my job is to assist students in finding books they'll enjoy. As I read this, I was as giddy as a 12-year old girl, a common behavior when I was a 17-year old boy. This is a dark book, which many young readers find valuable. It has the added risque pleasure of approaching some of our squeaky-clean telling of these tales (Disney, Pixar, et al) to reveal the sordid motives underneath. Turns out humans are easily corrupted, and ogres are matter-of-fact about their taste for man-flesh. 

3.) The heading pun was cheap, but I'm not out to win any awards. 

In which the author provides more context and confuses himself as to the issue

Compare this book to an emerging Hollywood trend: the amplified/bastardized fairy tale. Whatever you call it (my vote is for Aesop's Roid Rage), Koertge's book arrives as the appeal of this movement grows. Of course, Green Jello, beat them to it, in 1992: 

With the recent proliferation of films such as Snow White and the Hunstman, Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters, and the upcoming Jack the Giant Slayer, please, raise your hand if you don't see the pattern. 
[Classic Tale(Ultra Violence)+2(Sex)2  * focus group full of morons] = what film producers think we want.

What does this mean for YA readers? It seems like this is a transition; an adult version of something from one's childhood. This is the link between the two stages; this is what it means to be grown up! In fact, Koertge creates his own disturbing vision of Hansel & Gretel; they took care of the witch, but hate their parents, and do away with good old dad. There is more to what we've been told; kids can grow up to avenge their horrid past, become just as rotten as their oppressors, and vigilante justice is the name of the game. I recently read an article in The Atlantic, in which the author posited a somewhat specious argument that the rogue-cop film heroes of the 1980s, portrayed memorably by Sylvester Stallone (Rambo), Bruce Willis (John McClain in Die Hard) and Arnold Schwarzenegger (Commando; Kindergarten Cop) were a symbol of the Reagan era of rugged individualism, aggressive foreign policy, and increased defense spending. If that's the case (it's not)*, then what are these new breed of vigilante meters of justice? The author argues that the rogue cop action flick is dying; I would argue that it's taking a different form. Funny, in each of these new fairy tale films the villain is someone who is not quite human and/or lives a lifestyle outside of "normal" bounds; instead of communists or terrorists, they are giants, witches, and glass soldiers. However, dwarfs are acceptable allies. That's either a product of political correctness or Hobbit Fever. Are we saying that the 2010s is the decade of homogenization of our cultural heritage, and that anyone who strays from the narrative will be eliminated? If so, I should be a movie critic for a major magazine, because I can conjure sweeping generalizations from nothing!

In comparison, Koertge's book seems innocuous - a book tinged with dread, Bukowski-like in its wallowing study of depravity among the reprobates, even ending with an environmentalist message, but on the side of the fine line that makes it palatable for YA readers. 


*The author, Noah Gittell, does raise some salient points in his article, particularly about timing of the films' release and the politics of the aforementioned stars, which contribute to a convincing case, but it all doesn't add up. Boyish muscle fantasies come to life + nostalgia + knowing what sells, maybe, but the symbol of a political era? I can't make that leap.
Someone get me a pogo stick.

Boring Stuff

Lies, Knives, and Girls in Red Dresses 
Ron Koertge
Andrea Dezso (illustrator)
2012, Candlewick Press